Follow
Share
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Yes, my dreadful father was doing it the last time I saw him (a round trip to the UK from Oz – perhaps I was potty to bother). Any difficult topic, he would get wide eyed and make answers that sounded not quite there. I could pick it was faking because of long long experience with him (and I could usually guess why he was slipping out of discussing the item). I have not had enough experience with dementia to know if his ‘fake’ was spot on. He was quite sane when he was being nasty. I talked to the director of the NH, and she said that she had suspected the same thing.

My guess is that it would be hard to pick without experience with the person’s previous bad behavior. And I also suspect that acting it was actually risking his ability to pick when to do it and when not to. Acting ‘mad’ can send you down that path for real, unless you are very careful.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
JustDaughter Aug 2021
I can tell you from experience that a person will fall into familiar behaviors and speech patterns that will make them seem the same. Dementia doesn't begin from day one as "who areyou?" It's a little like a pile of leaves that blow away a few at a time. Some days a little wind kicks up and takes a bunch, other days just a couple, but the effect is cumulative.
(11)
Report
See 1 more reply
I can't imagine anyone faking dementia. I never once thought that of my mother.
My brother who lives at home has memory problems due to a major fall and hit his head. It is extremely forgetful. I did have him tested but neuro found no dementia but he does have memory loss from the fall which it can progress to dementia per his neurologist. We keep a close eye on him. I know he does not fake his memory loss. What is the point to it.
My mother on occasion complained that she does not have to feed herself because others do it for her. I did leave her alone one day, but I was peaking at her in the other room. I told her not to touch the food and when I left she picked up her spoon and started feeding herself. I even said to my niece we probably do too much for her and that might not be a good thing. I do not mind doing anything for my mom, but in the long run it is best to do as much as one can for themselves, but not with a lot of difficulty.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

It's funny, I often wonder how much is real and how much is fake? I've wondered the same thing too, and the conclusion I have reached is that it is all dementia-related behavior. Let's face it- normal people don't act like this.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
MargaretMcKen Aug 2021
The issue is that the people who 'act like this' aren't 'normal people'. Whether you blame them or not, they probably have always had personality/ behavioral shortcomings.
(2)
Report
Has she been formally tested?

Will it change HER needs or HER care plan if you are able to have her cognitive functioning formally assessed?

Do you have plenty of respite and relief time for YOU?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I think the better question is do they fake 'helplessness'? My father did that all the time. He couldn't be bothered to help himself, preferred I do as much as possible for him. It is like he didn't even know me as I rarely tolerated that kind of behavior. Didn't stop him from trying.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
BaileyP3 Aug 2021
My dad was the same way. Truth be told, he spent his entire life with my mom being taken care of so it stood to reason how helpless he seemed.

My husband's uncle was recently diagnosed with dementia, went into the hospital for a routine procedure and was transferred to an LTC after the diagnosis. The family is in huge denial and are waiting for him to get better and come home.

Dementia ebbs and flows; some days the patient seems their old selves, other days not so much. I've tried to explain it like a child that leaves home. They may come to visit and act like their younger selves but the fact of the matter is that version is gone and you'll only see their old selves in snatches of time. Best of luck.
(7)
Report
What sorts of examples can you give of this elder who you suspect is faking dementia for attention? What is she doing?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Do you know the signs of dementia when you see them? How exactly is she behaving for you to think she's faking dementia. Dementia shows itself as a multifactorial behavioral problem. Forgetting why you went into a room is, in itself, not dementia. Not remembering where you placed the keys or parked the car is, in itself, not dementia. Not recalling a long time recipe, in itself, is not dementia. There's much more to it than that. If someone is faking dementia, which a caregiver might suspect, but which I've never heard of, they would have to know and mimic the warning signs. If you're concerned, have her PCP screen her for dementia symptoms or see a neurologist.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I used to think my dad would “fake” not understanding to not have to deal with more difficult/complex things or to get people to leave him alone (which he very much wanted), but as time goes on I think he legitimately COULDN’T process anything or deal with people because of the dementia, not the other way around. It was just too overwhelming for a brain that wasn’t functioning correctly.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report

Please, please, please, don't treat someone cynically whose mind is failing. Have them checked out to find out what's really going on. Also take the time to educate yourself on dementia and what it looks like. No one is expected to be an expert the minute dementia rears its head, but make the effort to learn about the condition so you're better able to understand what may be going on. Check out Teepa Snow videos on YouTube and the Alzheimer's Association website (alz.org) to begin.

It would be unspeakably cruel to dismiss someone's health issues as an attention-getting tactic.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
JustDaughter Aug 2021
Not cruel. She's asking undoubtedly bc the individual has, in the past, caused her to doubt their honesty.
(8)
Report
See 1 more reply
I can't imagine that anyone would fake having dementia, as there are so many other ways to get attention.
Perhaps it's time to have her take a mental capacity test ordered by her neurologist. That will better help you understand exactly what is going on. Best wishes.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
jacobsonbob Aug 2021
Maybe a person who has OTHER mental issues would think of faking dementia as a prank. The only other reason would be if someone had done something wrong or made a serious mistake, and was trying to use dementia as an excuse.
(2)
Report
To my limited understanding, I would think not. I can’t imagine someone wanting to be deemed incompetent or willingly have their power removed from them just to be a burden to others or get attention.

Most likely what you are seeing is a person who used to crave attention, who eventually got dementia through no fault of their own.

Try to go easy on them, as hard as it can be. I wouldn’t wish dementia on my worst enemy.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
bundleofjoy Aug 2021
i’m not sure what i would wish on my worst enemy...

hmmm...

in any case, really i’m amazed how many wonderful people there are on this website. hugs everyone!! courage!!

bundle of joy :)
(5)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter