Follow
Share

My mother lived at home with part-time care by an unlicensed caregiver until a month ago. The woman seems sweet and well meaning, but her life is a mess, and she shared all her problems with my mother. Mother started giving her small money gifts and loans about three months ago---not much, maybe a total of $500 all told. When Mother went into assisted living last month, we gave her caregiver generous severance and a plan to work off the loans by weekly visits to my mother in the ALF and to Mother's house to water the plants. She did none of that until last week, when she took took my Mother on some errands. And Mother gave her another $100 "because she needs money so badly." We all live far away. What should we do? Mother isn't incompetent---she's pretty sharp in most ways---but she's unwise about money and a pushover for a sob story.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

23 Answers

Most
Helpful Newest
First Oldest
First
This experience has taught me to watch out for certain things when dealing with an irresponsible caregiver. I want to share some danger signals.

How does she talk about former clients and their families? Did the family "only care about Mom's money?" Were they "out for all they could get?" (Maybe the family had reason to worry about where Mom's money was going.)

When you're in town: is she "with another client" or "out sick" when you expect to see her? Does she fail to take or return your telephone calls and texts? Tell you her phone was out of order, she changed providers, she programmed it wrong, etc., etc.? (Avoiding you, feeling guilty, scared to talk to you.)

When you visit, is your Mom's pantry empty? Is the home low on or out of detergent, toilet paper, etc., even though groceries have been paid for? (Caregiver stocking her own pantry.)

Maybe the other clients' families were monsters, maybe the caregiver has a lousy phone and is sick a lot, maybe your mother is playing the ponies with the grocery money---but maybe, just maybe, you need to supervise the caregiver a lot more closely, or change caregivers.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Caryn, Thank goodness the family pays all her bills and monitors her accounts on-line. We make sure that the balance in her personal account is never enough to cause a real crisis if she gives it away. We don't think she or the caregiver is sophisticated enough about money to arrange a loan, change the signatories on the accounts (joint accounts with my sibling), sell the property or anything like that. Anyway, we're dealing more directly with this now. My sib---the money manager---has asked the caregiver for a weekly accounting of amounts received, purpose, and services rendered in return "for mother's records." I talked to our mother about it yesterday, explained that the woman now owed her many hours of services. As we talked, I realized that a big part of the problem is that my mother simply doesn't always remember writing the checks and what they were for, making it very easy for the woman to ask for more. She has already forgotten that previous loans are still unpaid. She has forgotten that the woman stopped visiting her and doing things for her for a period of weeks (until she had spent her severance pay, I assume). .
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Your mom feels sorry for the women and as long as the women is around your mother will give her money. When you talk about "small" amounts of money, unless you have access to her accounts, you really don't know how much she is giving away. Can she afford to give her money away? Is that her normal behavior?My mother put me on her bank accounts as a joint owner, so, I can go online and keep track of things for her and I am her only child. Now that she has had a series of mini strokes, has Dementia, and cannot handle her finances it makes it easy for me to handle all of her bills. I didn't know the full extent of my mother's misuse of her money until she moved in with me 3 months ago and I had to put her place up for sale. I went through all of her files looking for paperwork and couldn't believe how much money she spent. Now, that she needs money for her care, she can't afford it. We will supplement her monthly income for her care for the rest of her life. Fortunately, her doctor wrote a letter saying she can no longer handle her finances and her attorney sent me the Durable Power of Attorney. Now, I can sell her condo and take whatever money she has left and hope it's enough for assisted living for the next several years. My point is, if you think your mom is giving away only small amounts, you may be surprised! Maybe your mother can add you to her account(s) so you can help her too. I hope all the best to you and your family.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
ZoomDots, I'm with you. There are two sides to every story, and there are people who are true saints. I'm lucky to have known more than one. So it's important to understand where everyone in these situations is coming from---and then, as you say, make sure that the elder's or child's or disabled person's best interests are protected. Bless you for your giving heart.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
realtime, you're correct in that a caregiver from an agency knows they could get in trouble. But in the case with my mom, the caregiver and the agency head made sure to perform their business duties on the up and up. They also befriended her, therefore there were two separate relationships. So when mom gave them $$, it was to a friend. My lawyer says this is how they legally get away with it. I said what about the caregiver taking mom to the bank to get my name off the joint account saying to my mom "are you sure she isn't messing with your money"? He said you're mom is sane, it's her money. The caregiver told me once that mom was her client, I wasn't and families tend to get too involved when they shouldn't. It was a real eye opener. My son, from the very beginning told me the lady was up to no good, I should've listened before the emotional attachment began. And just to say, we were very involved in moms life. The "business" end went on in the day while we were at work. The "friend" thing when on at night when we thought mom/gma was safely ticked into bed. I guess where there's a will, there's a way and when the cats away, the mice (or rats) will play.
Good caregivers are a treasure to everyone. The bad apples, I hope, are few and far between.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
realtime, the helper is a woman that is mostly good but with some bad. I usually don't burn bridges completely with people who can be depended on for some things. For example, she does need money and will take my mother somewhere if needed. Having someone I can depend on is important to me. As long as she is not asking for money as a loan or gift, I am fine with it.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
It is so hard, because it is their money. But, what about the look back period, and how can you deal with that if they find she has given away money. I am dealing with this as my mom gave away money to all sorts of churches and charity causes. I tried to stop her years ago, but she said it was her money and she could do what she wanted. It was... but now I have to figure out what is going to happen for this look back time.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
as there are two sides too every story $$$
i am here to say that there are several famlies that i have worked for for free
as a god fearing woman who searches out the needs and well being of a
community that is desperate for decent persons who care about our elders
no matter the pay or not
worked with families who live in trailers or condos or mansions
as there are many an elder who can not speak to their own needs
there are many a family who needs to advocate for the true needs of their loved ones-"FAMILY OR NOT"
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
JessieBelle, If this woman works as a caregiver regularly, she must know that it's a no-no to accept money from clients. If she worked for an agency, she would be disciplined or fired for it. Good for you, that you put a stop to it! As to "she's not a bad person"---that's what I want to think about my mother's helper, but it's getting harder. Is this woman there for your mother when it's not a matter of getting paid? Does she ever call just to say hello or ask how she's doing? Does she avoid you and try to keep her relationship with your mother separate from you? Like you, I want to believe the best about everybody, but...but...but there are unscrupulous people in the world, and they do terrible damage. You're lucky your mother wasn't emotionally attached to her. If you think you may need help again someday, maybe you shouldn't count on this woman, but put out feelers to identify other helpers. If your mother can afford it, look at the home health companies, which hold their employees to a code of ethics.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
This same situation happened with my mother. She didn't particularly like the helper, calling her lazy and worthless, but she would "loan" her money. She said it was because the woman had a couple of kids and no money. The woman received child support from the father and money from the government. She drove a nice car, so my mother was just a little "supplemental income." She had no right to be asking my mother for money.

When I lived out of state I couldn't stop it. When I moved here, I stopped it fast.The former helper still owes my mother money. Boldly enough, she still calls her occasionally to see if she has any work for her. I don't tell her to get lost just in case we do need her one day. She is not a bad person, just doesn't grasp that her money problems are not her clients' responsibility.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Well, we've seen. In just the last week, Mother has given this woman at least $300 that we know about, possibly more.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Thanks for all the input. Here's an update. My mother's hairdresser witnessed a recent incident where my mother gave a "gift" to the ex-caregiver. She later told the woman privately that others might "misunderstand" the situation. The hairdresser called me to tell me what had happened and what she had done. She believes that the former caregiver is deliberately exploiting my mother, but that having it noticed by someone outside the family, in such a small community, might be enough to put a stop to it. We'll see.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
I think the behavior is partly a result of your mother's need to have a "friend" someone to talk to and depend on. I think it will continue as long as her family isn't available. You can hire caregivers to take care of an elder who lives in a different state or region but the family members need to be there. I would consider getting family members (children first, then older siblings, nieces/nephews) to either live with her or visit frequently. However, the same situation can occur with these family members who are "needy" in financial
issues.

Parenting or caregiving from a distance is almost impossible to pull off.

Good luck.

Elizabeth
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Realtime, your mother knows it's a sob story, because like you said she's got her wits about her. But this gal is paying attention to a lonely old lady, when it seems like the family can't or won't. So unless you're going to move mom closer to one of her kids, this is going to happen over and over again.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
This is a tricky situation. Your obviously concerned with your mom being taken advantage of, and although $100 here and there may not be a red flag, it could be the start of potential problems. It took a year after being widowed that my mom fell victim to a family "friend", who physically took her to her bank to withdraw $180,000 to send to China to a third party as an investment. Fortunately the ladies at the bank felt suspicious and called me to inquire if I knew the man my mom was with. I asked the bank manager to speak to my mom privately but the man with my mom said "whatever you need to discuss with her can be discussed in my presence", so at that point the bank called the police. The police, as someone posted, said it is her money to do as she wishes, but still escorted the man out and suggested to my mom that she call a family member or close friend to discuss this "investment". The bottom line is, there are nice people out there who just need help, and an elderly person may enjoy feeling needed and helping out. And there are other people out there who prey and may not maliciously intend to accept and take money from an elderly person, but get caught in a vicious cycle of receiving gifts and money that they simply can't say no to (even though they probably should when it's becomes habitual). Talking to the ex-caregiver, and making her aware that you are in the loop of things may help her tone down her sob stories to your mom, which she knows is only going to solicit money from her. Good luck with your situation!!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
I have seen aged persons fall victim to moochers--essentially con men and con women who stroke their egos, pretend to be their friends, and soak them for as much money, free rent, or valuables that they can get. The victims of moochers do not want to believe they are being used. The moochers will only go away when they can't get anything more from their victim. It's a difficult situation to deal with, when you're trying to help the victim.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
The caregiver/companion I helped my mom hire was very sweet-to my face- but she weasled herself into our family and I still to this day don't know what all she did or how much money mom "gave" her. It became a sticky mess and upon the advice of my lawyer, I didn't persue it because it's hard to prove any wrongdoing if your mom keeps everything a secret. I'm sure this sweetheart is part of the reason mom disowned me. So when mom died I was totally left out of the will and mom had every legal right to do so. The caregiver "took my place" as the oldest daughter. I told mom to spend her money and enjoy life but really didn't mean just blow it, give it away, etc. My son and I were POAs but she went to court when she disowned us and revoked it. That gave her and Ms. Caregiver free reign to do whatever. I didn't want mom's money except that part of her assests had belonged to my dad and believe me he wouldn't have been pleased about this if he were alive. Whatever...
Just please be careful how generous your mom is. If she's competent she can spend her money and you have no legal say. BUT if she spends it all and YOU have to pick up the tab for her care, I'd make sure you have control now or the future will be a nightmare!!!!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Unless your mother is giving her huge amounts of money or is signing a deed, etc. over to her, I wouldn't worry about it. $100 nowadays is not any great amount of money. Sometimes, it makes the person giving the money feel good to help others. Many people like to help other people financially.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
PS – I agree with caregiver75104, you should definitely be POA so that you can control how much money mom has on hand.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I agree, if your mom is cognitively competent to make decisions like this, then it's her money to do with as she pleases. And, if your mother is fairly secure financially, then we're not talking about significant sums of money here, YET. And, that's why I'd be concerned...if this is not typical behavior for your mom or if it's an exaggeration of her typical behavior, then she could be very vulnerable to to being taken advantage of. Maybe you could address this by including your mom. Your plan was to give the caregiver some sum once a week anyway. Why not have your mom hand it to her directly whenever she visits. I'm sure it bugs you that the woman showed up only when she needed cash, but if it's a good visit and your mom enjoys her company, why not allow that to be the payment arrangement (either explicitly or by just allowing it to happen)? You did characterize the woman as being sweet, so if you don't feel she is a serious threat (someone capable of plotting to extort serious amounts of money from your mom), you could just 'go with it' and keep a close eye on things. You may want to get the AL director in the loop so s/he can be on the lookout for anything getting out of hand.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Since it is your mother's money, she has the authority to do what she wants even if it seems like she doesn't handle it very well. If you are concerned about it and you should be, I would convince your mother that she should allow you to be her power of attorney so she doesn't have to deal with her finances anymore. Both of you will have to sign a legal document stating that you are her power of attorney and you will be making all her decisions for her.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
I care for my 96 year old mother who is blind, can't hear well and cannot walk. She has hospice workers who come to help with bathing, meds, and monitoring her health. She shares our monthly expenses from her Social Security check. She has a substantial amount of money in CD's and savings. Can I have her give me $200 a month for the care I provide her since I am with her 24/7 and I cannot work outside the home?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
If your mother is competent, then it is none of your business what she chooses to do with her money sorry
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

Recent Questions


Popular Questions


Related Questions

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter