Follow
Share

My 97 y.o. M.I.L. has lived with us for 3.5 years. She is a terror. She lies to us, curses. My question is: She makes $1,700 mo Soc Sec. When we go for respite care we use her money. We go once per week for 3 hours. We have had 2 overnight stays. We need more. She sends her 5 great grandchildren money every month. Some $50, some $100. They all are grown, and have very good paying jobs. They never say thank you. Is it wrong for us to stop sending them money so we can hire more caregivers so we can get away from her? My husband is her power of attorney in all things. She is able to go to day programs for free, but refuses to go unless she can take her dog. She cannot live alone as she forgets to feed him. AL was chosen, but all the extra services she would need would banckrupt both of us. Your honest advice is welcomed. She is low maintenance at home, but depends on us for her food, transportation. She causes us so much anguish. She is extremely opinated, and doesn 't care who she hurts. She has us hostage in our own home... Seems she has more rights than we do. Help.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
OP, you say that MIL “is able to go to day programs for free, but refuses to go unless she can take her dog”, and “we were told we can't make her by the social worker”.

No, you can’t “make her go”, but you can make it quite uncomfortable for her to stay at home instead of going. If you go out and leave her and the dog without a nice lunch, it will make her uncomfortable but it will not endanger her health or the dog.

All of us choose what to do or not do, because the result would be uncomfortable for us. Even quite young children learn to ‘weigh up consequences’. You are not powerless, don’t act as though you are.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

OMG!

My Mom has dementia. She is aware, yet not aware. She cannot write a check anymore. She would love to pass out all her assets to the grandkids before she dies. She says they need it more than she does. Each of the grandkids is able-bodied, smart and able to find a job, if motivated. I told my Mom NO. She CAN give Christmas money, however, she needs the money for her care. She doesn't understand. She still wants to simplify her finances by passing it all out to the grandkids before she dies. If we followed her wishes, that would leave my sister and I with the bill for her care. She doesn't understand nor care.

My Mother did not think she would live this long. She has been asking to die for the last 5 years (painlessly of course). She has a hard time hearing and comprehending and following instructions. She has severe arthritis whose pain is controlled to a dull ache with drugs. We spend about $200 on drugs and about another $150 in personal care per month, before room, board and food.

We have her in a Memory Care unit as she is needy, lies, negative, paranoid, stubborn, and manipulative with us kids, and that was before she had impaired memory. She doesn't present that side of her personality to outsiders. With Memory Care, I can walk away and leave her in caring hands when I cannot tolerate her during a visit. Thankfully, she likes the caregivers and nurses at MC. After being there for one year, her blood pressure was lower and she was actually healthier than when she was living alone and aggravating me.

I would research and see if you can find someplace suitable and within budget for her care. I know of at least one place where they had pets on-site. We didn't talk cost. I still take my Mom out for doctor's appointments, haircuts, restaurants, etc. She doesn't have any jewelry, credit cards, checkbook or money at the MC, so I'm not in constant "damage control" mode which took a lot out of me. Now I have options when the difficult behavior begins and know that she will still be in good hands.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Way2tired May 2023
Uggh Having same issues. FIL has checkbook and one credit card still . I’m worried about that . Insists he needs them .
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
From a fellow hostage....we are all in good company here! Does she have any assets? $$in bank? a homeowner? Medicaid has a 5 year look-back period and if there are little to no-assets, she may qualify for medicaid and they will pay for many of her needs, such as supplies, a live-in, or a 4 hour/day, or 8 hour/day personal assistant, As far as mailing checks out to family members, I would stop that. You owe no one any reasons. Shame on them if they question her or you about it. Good Luck.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

" They all are grown, and have very good paying jobs. They never say thank you..... Is it wrong for us to stop sending them money so we can hire more caregivers so we can get away from her?"
------------------------------------------------

NO!!! It is not wrong! You don't need anyone's approval to make sure her money goes to her care and grown adults do not need an allowance. Since your husband is POA can you make a plan with him to stop paying all the grandkids? He should be very involved, it's his mom.

One other tip: stop having so much vitriol/ hatred towards your MIL. She can't help her condition and she's not doing this on purpose. Yes, you need a break from caregiving but she also deserves to be cared for by people who do not resent her.... and you sound like you hate her.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
ventingisback May 2023
I don’t get the impression OP hates her MIL. I think OP is just honestly describing MIL’s personality.

I do get the impression that you, dkiely, luckily most likely care for a loving, appreciative mother. I hope so. Also, your mother lives alone, so you’re not dealing with her every minute in your home.

I think you’ve never cared for a mean person. And yes actually, some mean people can control themselves, but purposefully hurt others.
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hello. I can empathize as so many people on this forum can as well, with caregiver stress. I had a mess of stress taking care of my mom for 5 years, when she had Alzheimer’s. My mom tried a local adult activity center for 1 or 2 times, but she didn’t like being around the “old people.” (She was 89 at the time, and made it to 94). She’d also curse at Hubby and me, mostly me, over nothing. I had to remind myself that it was the disease talking. The following things helped me keep stress under control: I’d go for a walk, when it was reasonable and feasible. Hubby would look after my mom, and I’d either walk by myself, or with a friend in the neighborhood. I found that the walking and talking (if I were walking with my friend), was very therapeutic. I also found writing to be therapeutic and cathartic. I wrote down funny things that happened during my caregiving journey, like when my mom wanted to tell someone that she had pounded the pavement, looking for an accounting job in NY after college, but what she said was, “I walked the streets of NY, if you know what I mean.” My mom might have been a sweet talker, but she wasn’t a street walker. These musings became a book: “My Mother Has Alzheimer’s and My Dog Has Tapeworms: A Caregiver’s Tale.” (I thought of the title when I was driving home from work one day, and I realized that my once broad life was reduced to the pressing health concerns of my mom and dog.) I’d also watch TV at night, after my mom was safely in bed. Of course, I had to carve out time for the essentials in life: laundry, dishes, answering emails, etc., but I also dedicated some time to watching TV shows that I liked. Between real friends and the “Friends” TV show, I made it through. I hope the friends on this forum help you too.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Some ALs will take dogs. Stop sending money to grandchildren....she needs the money for her caregivers.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

FedupinCO: If the great grandchildren never say 'thank you' to her, that would be reason enough for her to stop the gifting. I have experienced this and I indeed did cease the underappreciated gifting. That was extremely difficult for me due to my caring nature.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Hire a lawyer.
Soon. I think you should have done this long ago.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Stop the gifting to anyone, this will hurt later in life if you need to apply for nursing home medicaid. Going thru this now with my mom. You really should consider placing her in a nursing home if you can. How did we end up like this.. being responsible for our parents, when can we live our lives! Going anywhere or having any kind of privacy in your own home is just about impossible! Oh and also take away any means for her to give away money. You should not be paying for everything yourself, just make sure you do not transfer money between her account and yours. I am learning a very hard lesson with nursing home medicaid lookback
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I hope your husband has both medical poa and financial which is durable poa. With these you have every reason to make all decisions. With Medicaid there are home services which may not cost anything. Taking back control will be so positive for all of you. Hire what you need. I use Alpha one for free caregivers. Take advantage of all services you can. You need to out live MIL.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Stop paying the "kids" - they don't need it and don't appreciate it. Use the money to hire more help. Get the respite you need.

Since MIL has a difficult personality, consider getting her help from a psychiatrist - geriatric specialty preferred. Also read any of the "boundary books" by Cloud and Townsend to create a plan for dealing with her problem behaviors.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Jennycap May 2023
agree - they need to take over all control of finances.
(2)
Report
No more gifts to ungrateful grand children. Have you spoken to them regarding accepting funds from an elderly person on a fixed income? What are they thinking? Ask if they want to pitch in with her care. Let your MIL know, as tactfully as possible, that giving away money she does not have will not be tolerated. You have created this monster. Explain her options to her, and let her know she can leave anytime she likes. You do not have to be cruel, just clear.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Stop the gifts and pay for help. Tell these adult grandkids what is up if needed…..they can pretend they get gifts. Or tell her it was sent…I tell my mom she has bought me gifts for holidays and I buy my own. She needs her cash for the AL bills! She is happy thinking she gave me something.. no harm in that!
.Good luck! If you do not have POA…see a lawyer and get it done..
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Honest opinion, the dog has to go (find a good home), you don’t need any extra responsibilities, stop sending money to GG kids. Sounds like your MIL is on Medicaid since she can go to programs for free. Tell her she is going to the program, this will give her the opportunity to get out of the house, meet new people and most of all give you and your husband a break. She will be given breakfast and lunch while you are doing whatever you need to do while she is gone. Medicaid also provides a few hours a week a home health aid. Check to see if your MIL is eligible for EBT (food stamps), every little bit helps.

She needs to be on a schedule that doesn’t include you and your husband constantly doing for her.

Try to limit your time around your MIL. This doesn’t give her the opportunity to give her opinion or hurt your feelings.

You and your husband are letting her control your home and make you feel like hostages. Stop it. Take control.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Jennycap May 2023
Agree.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Yes. It’s legal if he has POA for financial.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Deary me I'm in the same boat so I totally get where you're coming from. My 96 year old mother has lived with me since November 2017 when it became unsafe for her to continue to live alone. Years prior to that she had pleaded with me to never put her into a "nursing home" and I agreed without counting the cost. So here we are.

I've been caring for her in some form or fashion for 17 years, and as the duties have increased, my life has decreased. I almost have nothing left of my former self - my job, interests, hobbies, friends...all gone now. Some drifted away and others had to be put aside because I have no time to devote to them.

I'm also a hostage in my home unless a sitter is here - I now have 3 who come on various days for a few hours. I use my mother's SS income to pay them. Even with 3 sitters, I'm a prisoner in my own home most of the time. If I even walk out into the yard, I have to take an alarm with me in case she gets up from her chair or bed. It's like being on a leash 24/7.

The "please" and "thank you" are very uncommon. My mother has always had an attitude of sarcasm or "snarkiness" and it triggers the heck out of me.

To answer your question, yes, I think that you should use the amount of her money that you need to pay for more caregiver/sitters. You're doing all of the caregiving work so make no apologies and accept no false guilt.

Peace
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
betskand May 2023
Oh southie...your situation breaks my heart to hear about. I DO SO know that feeling of being a hostage and also of losing everything in my life: friends, health, even a tooth (which I don't have time to get replaced), exercise time such as long walks with a friend...my husband (93) seems to get physically stronger every day, but I feel as though I am 103 (I am actually 73). I just read a chapter in Sherwin Nuland's book, "How We Die," and (without specifically referring to caregivers) he points out that our vital left ventricles lose micro-patches of muscle with stress and hypertension. So the whole situation is killing US while it is keeping alive people whose loss of capabilities and understanding really should allow them to go.

Recently my hubby had a medical procedure done at the hospital (outpatient). It took about 3 hours of getting ready, waiting, and having the procedure. He was so nasty and demanding to EVERYONE that I felt I had to go around and apologize afterward. One nurse who helped with the procedure came to get me when he was ready to be rolled out to the car. He said, "Are you the primary caretaker?" I said, surprised, "Yes. How did you know?" He said kindly "You look like it," meaning that I looked exhausted, ground down, sad and despairing, I think. He said he and his sister had the same situation with their father. They could not be with him (both nurses), could not afford official home helpers or assisted living. Finally they found through a friend a young woman and her sister who were immigrants from Central America, intelligent and caring. Latin Americans have much more of a culture of families staying together and taking care of the elderly, and she had already taken care of her own mother and father. They moved in with the nurses and took care of the father for 7 years, until he died. He said they became like sisters to him and cost much less than official home helpers or assisted living. I live in a place with a lot of immigrants and am asking around trying to find such an experienced and trustworthy person who has taken care of someone here until he or she died. We can't possibly afford more than 2 years of assisted living or helper companies, and I don't think hubby will die that quickly, although I well may.

Nice to see your face always. You are indeed bella.
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
Absolutely, it is legal for you to decide for her.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Your MIL should stop sending money to her family and use it for her care. It's your house, with your rules, so do something to avoid burnout. You know, she could outlive you and require a facility anyway, so save yourself by moving her out to one now.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Stop sending money to her great grandchildren. We found out aunt ,94, was sending money to all kinds of charities and churches. Put a stop to that. That money should be spent on caregivers for her giving you a break, much needed. Caregivers can also prepare simple meals for her.

Try to put up some boundaries and set a schedule that suits you for doctor appointments. My parents about killed me running both of them each week to various doctors.

Please take her poor dog away and get him well cared for. He is a helpless animal and does not deserve to suffer with hunger. If she lives with you I hope some one takes responsibility for the pet.

Do not allow her to be so demanding and run your house.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Get her to grant POA to you and husband, or just husband. Then you have legal power to handle banking and other financial affairs. If you can't get POA, and maybe she's too far gone to grant it, you could get guardianship, but that's a long road sometimes. She appears to be batspit crazy, so certainly someone should be looking after her medical and financial affairs at this point. If she qualifies for Medicaid, surely you could find a place for her and her dog. Some care facilities do take pets.

I believe you need an eldercare attorney. Pay for it with her funds.

I sincerely hope you can get this resolved sooner rather than later!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
FedupinCO May 2023
Yes, thank it. I had major open heart surgery in 2021, and my husband and I were separated for 4 months...so much stress!!
(1)
Report
I lived like this for awhile but my mom wasn't exactly that bad. Do what you need to keep your sanity. If you need more help then get that help. At her expense and her your husband is her poa and it is so important for you to get rid of the burn out and it shouldn't have any problems legally. I started doing it with my mom.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Providing housing & hands-on care for your MIL has been a large generous gift.

But not all gifts are like a no limit, no expiry gift card.

If this current plan is no longer working, time to re-assess. The household plan needs to work for EVERYONE in.the household. Not just MIL.

Mission creeps happens!
But it's fixable.

MIL can have the dignity of 'paying her way'. To pay for her care/respite care/aides etc.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My first suggestion would be to write to the 5 descendants she sends money to, and say that her own care needs more funds than are available. Explain that DH has POA and needs to stop sending the money so that it can be used for better and more appropriate care. Ask them to let you know (with details) if this will cause serious difficulties for them.

Than stop it!
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
FedupinCO Apr 2023
Thank you for responding. My concern is it legal to decide for her?
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter