Follow
Share

My mother is a 75 year old ill woman who is practically unable to walk any longer due to her illness (COPD, Emphysema, Asthma). Its bad.
She was an absolutely awesome mother to me in my childhood. She made mistakes like everyone, myself included. Looking at the big picture she did well and I was brought up correctly. When she became ill some fifteen years ago, she started changing.
We are now at the point where I try to see her twice a week so that I can make sure that I have no regrets like with my father. I was in my twenties and regretted not spending more time with him when he was at the end of his time due to Cancer. It still bothers me.
I cannot even be in the same room as her any more. We end up arguing from sentence one. She is ultra defensive at all times. Today I said that the carpet needs a clean and she took it as me accusing her of being a dirty person. Which then turned into "the carpets are stained and cannot be washed", which is some sort of excuse strategy she has been employing. Often some made up thing in her mind that she believes in the moment. Another example is that I go to her home only to wash my clothes. I am a 37 year old man who has lived by himself for many years, and I have my stuff (imagine). I don't rely on her for any funds or anything really for over a decade. I only go to her home to actually see how she is doing and spend time with her.
I do suspect some sort of geriatric issue with her. Perhaps the lack of oxygen all these years has sped this up.
All I want to do is exist with her in a room, have a conversation that isn't making both of us depressed, and somewhat improve my our relationship before she is gone.
I am all ears people.
Greetings from South Africa.

Find Care & Housing
My Mom died from COPD at age 76, my sister from it at 56.

It's a brutal disease, usually from years of smoking. Don't expect your Mom to be cheerful and happy anymore. I think most all our Mothers seemed so amazing when we were young.

She's lost her husband, her health has gotten worse and she's in survival mode at this point. People with COPD don't live into their 80s. Anything you say is going to been taken or seen as criticism. She doesn't want to hear anything from someone so lucky to be in their 30s.

It sounds like Mom doesn't want to socialize. You can't force a happy relationship with someone so obviously bitter about her current, terrible life, which is nearing the end.

I would limit visiting Mom. You could try to bring her some flowers, or some food she loves. Otherwise, keep it to quick phone calls. You can't make her happy, so stop trying.

Don't take it personal. Be glad she doesn't want you moving in, or for you to be caregiving. That doesn't mean you tolerate the abuse. In her situation, any conversation that gets ugly should be your cue to leave.

I wish I had better advice. My Mother was terrible at the end.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Dawn88
Report
SafaCD Feb 18, 2026
Hi Dawn, appreciate you sharing your story. Yes watching mom deteriorate just like Dad has been terrible. I want to help her but at this point I cannot.

So scary to think this was from smoking, she stopped at 44 but it never reversed.

Mom does want to socialize that is the thing. She is very lonely and reaches out at times just to talk. I am one of the few that do and I feel as her son its my responsibility to try be there. She was there for me after all.

Il try the advice of short and "sweet".
(0)
Report
It’s very kind of you to visit your mother. I recommend you gain acceptance of her new reality and have realistic expectations of what the relationship will now be. She’s lost whatever happy was for her, as she’s lost her spouse, her health, and her abilities. Often, when the losses pile up, happiness ends and bitterness sets in. This is not something you can change. When you visit, talk only about inane things like the weather, stay only briefly, and know that silence is okay too. Go determined not to take the bait of anything that leads to an argument. Take her something she enjoys, something small. Leave when she gets argumentative, without explanation “see you next time, hope you feel better” Most people have some regrets of things we could have done better, I certainly do, but I’ve also learned that beating myself up over it doesn’t change it, I can only do better in the future. You can’t fix mom, or likely have a close relationship, but you can both visit to show respect and protect yourself from her negativity. I wish you peace
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

A relationship cannot be forced. Nothing you do will change that, so stop beating yourself up. It's not your fault.

It sounds like your mother is having cognitive issues. Never argue with someone who has cognitive issues, because they no longer have the capacity to reason or have deep meaningful conversations.

If she starts being unpleasant, end the visit or phone call. Stop rewarding bad behavior. Stop subjecting yourself to mental torture.

Say something like "Mom, I'm sorry you're not feeling well. I'll check in with you later. Bye - I love you."

Ask her doctor to prescribe an anti-depressant. It helped my mom immensely.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Dogwood63
Report

Two thoughts based on this short quote from your post. "Today I said that the carpet needs a clean and she took it as me accusing her of being a dirty person. Which then turned into "the carpets are stained and cannot be washed", which is some sort of excuse strategy she has been employing."

The first reaction is if you came to my house when I was quite ill and told me my carpets were dirty I'd be annoyed too. It doesn't seem important in the grand scheme of things and I'm not sure why you pointed it out, unless what you really said was mom I'd like to send the carpet cleaning company to make your house nice for you.

The excuse strategy you reference on her part looks like it could be confabulation. Confabulation is when a person with cognitive decline isn't able to think and reason properly and so in a panic they start making up answers that sound good. Often they will make up a different answer to the same question each time you ask it. It's maddening when you think they're doing it on purpose but it's understandable when you realize they're trying to please you (or get you off their back) with a plausible answer. They don't know the real answer any more.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Slartibartfast
Report
SafaCD Feb 18, 2026
Thank you for alerting me to the condition of Confabulation, Makes total sense.

Mom talks about the carpets every time I enter the house for five years. I am just talking about what she talks about to find commonality. I was actually going to discuss cleaning the carpets there as well as my own but we didn't get that far.
(1)
Report
Go see mom with the attitude of being a loving and helpful son. To see what you can do for her now that she can barely breathe, rather than using her washing machine and pointing out her dirty carpet. Do you think she cares about a stained carpet at this stage in her life? Or that your clothes need washing? If you go there w/o clothing to wash, then you're only going there to see HER, nothing else. She's a defensive person so don't give her ammunition.

Bring flowers
Ask if she needs groceries
Make her a cup of tea or hot chocolate
Bring a cake by and share it
Bring by photos to look at
Play soft music
Watch a comedy show and laugh together

My mother had dementia and was impossible to talk to. I'd bring her snacks because theres no need to force conversation while eating. Distraction techniques work better than trying to drum up conversation which can always go south. Stick to neutral subjects that she cannot take offense to. The weather, the garden, things like that. Try a stroll outside in a wheelchair if at all feasible. In other words, do anything to keep her occupied and non argumentative. My mother would holler black if i said white. So the key is to keep conversation at a minimum while still spending time together. Look at a new magazine. Rag magazines like People can keep you both occupied laughing or clucking your tongues at outrageous celebrity fashion or behavior, then you have a snack, watch TV and it's time to leave.

Get creative. Mom's in a bad mood and argumentative due to probable cognitive decline. That can be very challenging. But if you play your cards right, you'll both have a semi pleasant visit and you'll leave feeling good instead of wanting to pull your hair out.

Good luck to you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
SafaCD Feb 18, 2026
I don't use her washing machine? Not sure where you read that. I said that is what she thinks I see her for in the moment of her anger. She absolutely cares about a stained carpet this stage of her life. Its one of the things she takes pride in actually.

I have tried to get her outside with assistance. She does not want to go anywhere, with exception of the casino once a week, which my brother tends to. Gambling is the only thing that excites her to force herself to get out. Makes no sense to me but if it brings her joy great.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Stop visiting her. Have a phone call with her once a day. Be pleasant. As soon as the conversation becomes unpleasant, whether because of something you said or something she said, say, "Goodbye. I'll check in with you again tomorrow." Stop torturing yourself trying to force a relationship that you imagine you can have, and accept the one that you do have. Stop torturing yourself about whatever did or didn't happen with your dad, and letting this affect your relationship with your mother. You say she immediately gets defensive, but it sounds like you do too. Just let her be. I wish you peace and acceptance.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MG8522
Report

Perhaps just one visit a week would be better for now, and you can call her on the other day instead, and the minute the conversation turns negative, you tell you you have to go/hang up now, and you'll talk to her another day when she can be more pleasant.
But don't hold your breath on that one, as her being pleasant days may sadly be over for her. And it's not your responsibility to make your mom happy or her days pleasant.
And if in fact you are doing your laundry at her house, find someplace else to do it, as it will be one less thing for her to complain about.
I wish you well in dealing with your mom and know that all things can not be fixed and often we just have to make the best out of things, best we can.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report
SafaCD Feb 18, 2026
no laundry...
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
There is often depression that comes with age-related cognitive decline, as well as the reality of her very limited current and future health. IF you have any influence with her doctor(s) perhaps suggest addressing her depression with medication. My Mom started taking the lowest dose of Lexapro and it has helped her mood a lot (not perfect, but it has been helpful).

When you visit, try rephrasing things into questions so she feels like she's the one making decisions: "Mom, do you need any help with upkeep? I can find services to help keep your apartment clean so that you can enjoy it." And then accept if she says no and move on.

My 96-year old Mother lives next door to me and has moderate dementia. When I go there I always try to bring something to give her: her favorite fruit, dessert, newsletter. My husband has a trick where, if she starts going down a negative or paranoid path, he starts showing her pictures of cute animals or funny pratfalls by people. If I'm there by myself and can't turn around her Bad Mood ship I pretend I'm getting a phone call and run out the door. Often I will hang up on her if she is irrational. You can't pick your family members but you can pick your boundaries with them.

You aren't responsible for her happiness. When visiting, don't have any expectations for how it will go. Expectations are premeditated disappointments. Bless you for trying so hard but now you will need to come to peace with the reality of her present and future. It won't get better for her. You won't be able to make her happy. Do what you can accept but do not feel guilty for any outcome. Most people don't have consciencious children like you, so count her blessings for her. May you receive peace in your heart on this journey.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
SafaCD Feb 18, 2026
Wise advice I believe, I will give it a try.
Thank you.
(1)
Report
To spend time together and have talks that don't depress you both, you might try sampling and listening to a little bit of music together. Ask her what she likes and try to find that song or artist on your phone, if you have a smart phone. Or play something you like and let her complaint about it! Even if she says she’s not interested, keep doing it. With so little to occupy her aging mind, she may eventually see the activity as a positive, well-intentioned one. She might enjoy criticizing the music and you don't have to be the recipient of her acrimony. 

Others here are so right: she is winding down her life and it's painful in every way, so of course she's testy. And you have a right to limit your time with her. However, if you really want to try "the impossible" and see if you can turn things around before she is gone, maybe ask questions about her deepest, most painful regrets or fears or hurts in her life. I did that with my parent and it turned out to be healing for us both, also very hard but worth it. I listened and she talked, a lot. Eventually, she ran out of regrets, anger and criticism, of herself and toward others (which was basically me because I was present with her at the end) and she found a sunny spot to be in, right up until the end of her life. I don't know what's possible with you and your mom but I hope there is a change. You're doing a good thing, just being there and checking on her.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to FeelsThinks
Report

If it was me, I'd tell her my work schedule changed - and I'll only be able to see her once a week now - but, will make up for that by bringing a surprise snack every time.

I'd pick a snack at the store that reminds me of her and my childhood. And when I visit, say "I brought you this!" smiling, remember the time we .... and then share a brief memory.

Wouldn't stay long, once she starts getting irritable! And would not bring laundry. Don't do your laundry there, because she knows you're stuck there - until it's dry.

Just bring you, a treat, and a short, happy visit. And don't worry about little things around her house.

Make the focus: Enjoyment & a treat. Just try to enjoy the Mom that you love during your visit.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to QuiltedBear
Report
SafaCD Feb 18, 2026
again guys, i don't do laundry there haha.
(0)
Report
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter