Follow
Share

My husband with vascular dementia is in a memory care but high functioning. He wants to come home. He thinks he can do the things that he used to do. Most of the time, he seems lucid. But I don’t want him to come home. I don’t even want to be married to him. My question is, if he leaves memory care, he would be in a senior apartment and I’d need to hire a full time companion for transportation, cooking, light housekeeping and company. How do I go about hiring someone like that? Has anyone else gone this route?

Find Care & Housing
I know you will receive a lot of good advice from experienced care givers here. My 94 year old dad is showing signs of cognitive decline (but also has chronic UTIs, and many other health issues that may be contributing to how he presents). So, I have been reading responses concerning dementia here a lot!

Many have said over and over, that the dementias are not something that can be healed/fixed and the person will continue to decline in cognition and ability. Many people with dementia are able to “show time” (if I have the right expression), when they are motivated—temporarily able to appear more capable than they really are. So, even if your husband could be safe in independent living with a caregiver now, I would question for how long and how safe? You have already gone through the hard work to have him placed, I would question why you would step out of that now? What happens when he declines and you have to then get him placed somewhere again?

To hire a full time caregiver, I have read there are many avenues. An agency could send people to cover all shifts, for 24/7 coverage. They advertise that they vet their people and of course they take care of all the taxes and insurance, etc for them as employees. I understand you can also get caregivers via the VA, if you or your husband served. Some people hire someone privately but then you have to vet them and take care of taxes and insurance etc. All avenues, I have read, have positives and negatives. One such negative is when caregivers do not show up unexpectedly, then you are left to try to coordinate someone or caregive yourself.

I would recommend that you very carefully consider all this, and I wish you peace and comfort in your future.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Hope21
Report

Welcome, Yesterday!

Wouldn't acceding to his demands be an exercise in futility? Vascular dementia usually progresses pretty quickly--my mom died almost 5 years to the day from her diagnosis.

Can he afford a senior apartment and a full time caregiver?

You would need to find someone who could withstand his attempts to "fire" him/her.

If he were in a "regular" living environment, would he be considered competent to get rid of caregivers himself? What would YOUR legal liability be?

I would consult an Elder Law attorney before making any moves.

Pleasing him may not be the best goal here.

Best of luck to you both.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to BarbBrooklyn
Report
Yesterdayanurse May 3, 2026
I just don’t know what to do. He is driving me nuts, calling all the time, saying he needs to be home with me to “help me” and that he doesn’t plan on staying there much longer. He has conversations with me like he has nothing wrong. I doubt at times that he even needs to be there. My goal was to put him in assisted living. They said he was exit seeking. So he’s in a locked unit. I feel guilty about having him locked up. Especially when he seems cognizant. If vascular dementia is a five year life span, his progression seems to have slowed down. I just want this to end.
(1)
Report
How will he be able to leave memory care if you don’t assist him in doing so? Will another family member remove him?
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
Yesterdayanurse May 3, 2026
I’d have to do it.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
What can he afford? His health is going to decline, and when he's no longer high functioning, he'll need more than a companion. I hired the caregivers for my dad, who then stayed on after his death to care for my mom. I hired and supervised all of them. They didn't work for an agency.

We needed a 24/7 live-in caregiver who was a CNA. We needed two other caregivers to help her, stay with the patient when the 24/7 had to go out, help with the Hoyer, the housekeeping, and all the things that are required when someone is sick at home. We had a once-a-week housekeeper, and I was there often to help with the shopping and cooking as well as patient care. This cost around $100,000 a year, and that was many years ago. My parents' dying took 5+ years.

In addition, you'd be paying rent on an apartment as well as utilities and other expenses attached to it. Food - you'll need to feed the 24/7 because she lives there and cooks for the patient, though she might buy some of her own food; she might not have time to cook for herself as well as the patient. Full-time dementia care requires full attention of at least one person and preferably more. If you're the manager of all of this, consider it a full-time job.

I hope your husband stays where he is. They already have the resources that he will need, and that will be easier on you.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

What do you do when the caregiver gets sick? Then you're up the creek.

Tell your husband he "can come home when the DOCTOR says he's in good enough shape to come home, but not till then." Then change the subject. He's Showtiming for you and acting as though he's perfectly fine when he is NOT. Or he wouldn't be in Memory Care. He's manipulating you, just as my mother manipulated me when she lived in Memory Care. Insisting she was fine, all "the others were crazy, not her". She could come live at my house and HELP ME. Ridiculous statement that was, in reality. She suffered from anosognosia which is the inability to recognize or acknowledge her deficits. A common issue with folks suffering from dementia and/or schizophrenia and other mental health issues. They gaslight us, trying to say WE are crazy and THEY are fine. Don't fall for this tactic, and stick with the line about the doctor. Blame him.

Taking DH out of MC and setting him up in his own place with a live in is insanity. It'll turn into YOUR living nightmare 100%.

As far as guilt goes, consider you're feeling grief instead and remember you're doing nothing wrong to be accusing yourself of guilt. Blame the disease of dementia for all of this, not yourself, and leave DH where he's best cared for and safe every day.

Best of luck to you.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

You hire enough to only pay for 40 hours a week, so you need several. You want to avoid overtime. You have to provide their tax info. Paying under the counter leaves things untraceable and if Medicaid is needed will be considered as gifting, thus leaving him ineligible.
Or you can make it easier on yourself and hire an agency. Find out the hourly rates and do the math.
Either way, will cost much higher than a nursing home. For example figure on 15 to 19 k each month.
Do you have deep pockets? Otherwise, you keep saying you will not take him in to your home.
And BTW, you can block his phone calls. It sounds like he has a repeating mantra. He might need calming meds. This sounds like Lewy body dementia
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to MACinCT
Report

" I just want this to end."

One way for it to end is if you take him out of his locked memory care unit and he takes off from the apartment you rented because the caregivers you hired are insufficient to manage him.

My husband got out of our house, which I'd worked hard to make secure so he couldn't wander. He ended up in a hospital many miles away as a John Doe. While I was frantically looking for him, good Samaritans saw him walking on a busy highway, called an ambulance and sent him to the hospital. Fortunately he was okay, but he could have been hit by a vehicle, fallen into a ditch, or jumped off a bridge. Or robbed. Or beaten.

A locked unit is the only place a dementia patient needs to be when they get to that stage. You'd feel much more guilty if you take him out of there and he dies as a result of your negligence. Look up the laws in your state and find out what you could be charged with if your "just wanting it to end" results in his death.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

Don't remove him from his current facility. It's hard to deal with dementia in someone you love, but bringing him home would not help him or be safe for either of you. He may seem lucid at times, but still need 24/7 care. Don't let the lucid moments fool you. He is getting worse and will continue to need care this facility provides. You may ask his doctor about meds. You may want to get a full check up as well and discuss your feelings with your doctor.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to JustAnon
Report

First, you tell him a therapeutic fib as others have suggested: "When your doctor thinks you're ready for an assessment then you can discuss it with him/her"

Next, you get him on meds for depression/anxiety/agitation.

Then, you understand that wanting to "go home" is a dementia behavior called Sundowning. Often he's not even thinking of his most recent home, but a safer one, in his long-term memory, like from his childhood. You redirect the conversation or distract him. Don't talk to him or visit him in the afternoon as it tends to be worse then. Let his calls go to voicemail and screen them. Once he starts on the going home topic, you change the subject and keep redirecting it. If it's getting him wound up, then make an excuse to hang up.

Hiring aids will be like another full-time job. I hired aids for my Mom when she was recovering from a broken pubic bone. Even the agency couldn't keep enough people and it was a parade of newcomers almost weekly. Finding subs at the last minute is a royal pain and often impossible. All the more worse if you privately hire: many states say you are now an employer and need to have contracts, do payroll withholding, quarterly reporting and issue W2s. To top it off, you lose all your privacy in your home, which is what my Mom hated the most.

Please do not take him out. Keep reminding yourself he is in the most appropriate care for the BOTH of you.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

You say he can't be in assisted living because he is exit-seeking, and is currently in memory care where he cannot escape. What on earth would happen if you moved him to an independent living apartment?! He wants to be "home with you". He will likely try to leave anywhere to find home.

I'm sorry you are finding it confusing or stressful because he is showing signs of lucidity, but he will only continue to further decline. I think he is where he needs to be. If the cost is an issue, obviously an independent apartment will cost far less than long term memory care. You can try that route if you think it will work for now, but don't expect it to go smoothly or last for long.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report
KPinSC May 9, 2026
I believe an independent apartment would be about the same or even maybe more than memory care because of the 24/7 private caregiver expense. It definitely would not be as safe.
(0)
Report
He is where he needs to be . Leave him there.
If he leaves , he will no doubt say he’s fine and fire the companion .
Maybe he needs a med to calm him .
He’s not the first to say he doesn’t belong in memory care and beg to go home and he won’t be the last.
Visit less often . Visits short . Don’t answer your phone , let it go to voicemail . Only speak to him on the phone once every 3 days . The more attention you give to this behavior , the more he will keep it up , because it gives him hope of leaving.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to waytomisery
Report

Full time care requires 3 eight hour shifts each day for 7 days in each week, and is staggeringly expensive. There is also the ‘no show’ problem, where you would need to organise care for any times when one of the many carers didn’t come. It isn’t a question of simply finding a full time carer. Work out the cost, and ask him how HE is going to pay for it. Split your finances if necessary.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

He needs to stay exactly where he is. He cannot leave. It doesn't matter what he wants. He is where he should be.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to olddude
Report

Keep him where he is.
Tell him :
"I am working on it"
"We can discuss this with your doctor at the next visit"
What you are proposing is expensive.
Contact a few agencies and tell them that you need a "live in" or several shifts to cover 24 hours.
Now add the cost of the apartment, food, insurance, utilities (gas, electric, cable), transportation.
If your husband is taking any medications most agencies will not provide a "companion" you would be charged for someone that has more training.

You say "most of the time he seems lucid"
I am assuming that you are not with him 24/7. So, he may be putting on a show for you letting you think he is more capable than he really is.
He is safe where he is. He is cared for where he is.
If this was not the correct placement for him the facility would have suggested Assisted Living rather than Memory Care.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report
KPinSC May 9, 2026
Memory Care is Assisted Living.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I am sorry that you are going through this. Many of us are in a similar boat. Hiring a full time caregiver is next to impossible in this country. The costs are through the roof. Plus will this caregiver ever be a clone of you? Cook, clean, be a companion, be a health professional etc etc. Maybe you have in the correct place already. Maybe visit him often so he doesnt feel like hes in this alone? No good answers. In my case, I have left it up to God.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to NG2025
Report

Parkinson's as well as vascular dementia are progressive. PD related dementia is often accompanied with lewy bodies. Both PD and LBs can be very fluctuating with their symptoms having calm periods and chaotic periods.

If you remove him from memory care and he suddenly progresses to a lower cognitive and physical level, how would you deal with that. I have not dealt with facilities yet, but understand finding an appropriate one to accept someone with either vascular or lewy types of dementia can be very difficult because they can become very aggressive.

My suggestion is leave him where he is since the staff is already familiar with his current traits and hopefully will be more tolerant and understanding as his disease processes.

We tried an independent senior community a few years ago and it became stressful because there were so many other residents who expected us to help them when their caregiver was off... much like I would expect your husband would be unless you have 24/7 care. They were allowing some to come in with caregivers providing simple medication reminders who needed a lot more supervision and became a burden to the other residents.

Should this happen, you would have spent a lot of money settling him in then if needed, the memory care facility may not take him back and you would be back to square one with full responsibility while looking for a new facility.

Sounds to me if you truly don't even want to be married to him you would be setting yourself up possibly for a total fiasco and in a lot worse scenario! Step back and consider the freedoms you have now that you would lose... even with 24/7 caregivers you would have to oversee his care plan and probably need to be involved much more than you envision. When you hire an agency to send caregivers, that is all they do.... send caregivers and let you know if someone calls out and if they can't be replaced for that shift.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to KPinSC
Report

You can have an assessment done mgt a geriatrician or certified nurse practitioner or someone who is certified in providing nursing assistance in a home health care environment and they would determine, the needs, wants, and equipment and costs of what would be necessary and the diagnostic requirements for services. Hope you find the information helpful.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Senior8
Report

Leave him where he is as he’s in memory care stage, which means 24/7. Senior apartments are usually for people closer to independent care,
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to PeggySue2020
Report

Full time 24/7 care can be found through Home Care Agencies or from people who do this work independently outside of agencies. The level of care can be adjusted to meet whatever his needs are. Basic daily living care is expensive and higher levels of care are even more expensive. You can do this if you have the resources, but your husband's care needs may progress beyond what any care giver can manage and he might ultimately end up in memeory care again anyway .
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to RedVanAnnie
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter