Follow
Share

Background: Dad is AL with a lot of health issues and suspected early dementia (suspected not just by me. His PCP also thinks it's the case, but getting a full diagnosis is hard, especially since dad refuses to acknowledge he's having issues and threatens suicide anytime someone mentions the idea)



He's been doing really well at AL. His diabetes in particular, wow, they manage that so well — but he's also has some rage issues, which we think are related to his memory loss.



The AL has a program that provides talk therapy to residents who qualify. It's paid for by Medicaid. They recommended that he do this, because of his anger situations (he's broken stuff, yelled at people, it's not good). I agreed.



But, if I told my Dad he needed "a shrink" he would freak out. So we made it out that this is something everyone gets. I thought I'd see how it works.



The thing is, he loves it! He thinks it's dumb, "I don't need therapy." But then he talks about the woman who comes. "She asks me a lot about my family and I get to talk about stuff."



Dad has struggled with his emotions a lot in this phase of his life and I love that he has a therapist — paid for by Medicare! But he has no idea that I arranged it and that it's not everyone in AL.



I hate lying to him because it always bites me on the butt, but I feel like I might need to keep this one up.



What do you think?

Do what you have to do if you think it’s helping him.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Southernwaver
Report

What would be the benefit of being completely honest with him about this? You already know how he’ll react. There is no harm allowing him to believe that the therapist is just a nice lady who comes to talk to him.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to RLWG54
Report

Let's say you tell him the truth, he freaks out and stops going. He no longer gets the benefits of talk therapy. If you keep up this teeny tiny insignificant-in-the-grand-scheme-of-things-fib, he thinks he's in control and helping himself by his own choice. And your relationship with him is benefiting as are the ones where he lives. There are lies and then there are LIES. Yours fits into the former. And no one is getting hurt by it.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to NYDaughterInLaw
Report

Do whatever it takes to get him help. It's a positive thing! It could be the best thing ever for Dad now, so keep the ego out of it.
You only put in for "extra free stuff." What's not to like??
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Dawn88
Report

Don’t tell him the truth .

This talk therapy is helping him .

My mother was similar , at first she wasn’t aware either .

She was telling me about the “ male nurse “ that was coming around . Mom assumed it was a nurse. In reality the therapist never said what his function was .

He just told her he visits and talks to the residents to see how things are . Mom assumed it was like a survey or something to give feedback to the facility lol. She got to complain about everything and everyone , including me for placing her.

Mom loved it too , she said “ he listens to me”.

Unfortunately , a staff member let the cat out of the bag to Mom by mentioning how nice the “ psychologist is “ right after he left Moms room .

Mom never would speak to him again . Because she said “ she wasn’t crazy “.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
MissesJ Nov 13, 2024
Well, at least Gen X won’t have that attitude regarding therapy. 😬
(3)
Report
That's great. It is just group talk. There's no lie whatsoever in that.
Do what WORKS. You are dealing with a disease here and a disordered mind that cannot grasp real discussions. Your GOAL IS COMFORT for him, and as much happiness as you can find in anything. It's wonderful that he enjoys this.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

OLD POST
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to southernwave
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter