Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I’m sorry your husband had a stroke. It’s got to be a challenging situation.

Your sister & her husband want 6 weeks support while they take on the remaining 46. They carry the burden so yes, you lack compassion and show little understanding about the role of daughter/son-in-law-caregiver when the parent lives longer than the caregivers’ expectation. Your sister and BIL are making sacrifices to give your mother a lifestyle she wants. So yeah, they get to feel like a saint and martyr and everything in between.

It doesn’t sound like you wanted your sister to consider your opinion; it sounds like you wanted your way and resent the fact that they didn’t take it and want help. Your sister is saving your mother the cost of being in a facility. If there’s an inheritance left because of this, do you expect to inherit? And if your mother doesn’t have the money for a full-time facility, are you offering to pay for it?

If you can’t handle three weeks, ask for 3 two week periods and hire help for your mother and husband. Or pay for your mom and/or husband to go to a respite caregiver facility (places designed to give caregivers a break).

PS. if your sister hadn’t taken in your mother, would she have spent Covid years in assisted living lockdown?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Way2tired Jun 2023
Erikka, OP sounds like she is not in the position to take care of the mother right now . It’s too much for her . It doesn’t mean the derogatory assumptions that you have extrapolated from her post . Which imo are off base .

The issue now is that the mother needs care. Why should OP pay for the mother’s care ? She’s not obligated to spend her money on the mother , especially when she may need it for her husband’s care .

Do you think OP should pay because the sister is saving the mother money and possibly inheritance as you mentioned ? Retirement savings should be used to take care of the person in retirement . That’s what it is for. I can’t stand when people say that their inheritance is being wasted on a nursing home. There is no such thing as inheritance until the person dies .

The mother’s own money should be used to pay for her care whether it be help coming in or a respite facility.

I took care of both my parents without the help of my 4 siblings, nor did I ask for help . I did not feel like I had the right to act like a saint or a martyr .

You can’t force caregiving on someone else . If the sister needs a break she makes other arrangements if OP can’t help . It’s that simple . If OP wants , she can help find a respite facility and visit the mother . The guilt trip you put on is ridiculous .
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
"I feel like we can't refuse to keep her because ... "

There is NO because and YES, you can refuse them.

If you believe or feel you are 'being a selfish wench?' you will feel this way.
Examine your belief system. Beliefs can be changed as one decides to do so.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Yes you should refuse, and no you should not feel guilty or selfish.

If your sister was unfathomably stupid enough to take in your mother, that’s her problem. She should be in a nursing home.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

If money isn't a problem and you and your husband have always been happy to contribute financially, how about offering to pay for respite care to give the primary caregivers a break? Why does having her in your home have to be the only option?
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

You & sister need to reevaluate the plan. First see elder law attorney for guidance. If she has $$$ & assets, you get directions on how to get Medicaid. Does she have long term care insurance? Was her husband a veteran? She can get aid & attendance from VA which helps pay for private aide. In any event, situation needs to change. I hope you can work with sister for a solution. Hugs 🤗
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
NeedLove2 Jun 2023
I also responded to this person. I am my mom's caregiver. My dad died 2 years ago, very unexpectedly and my mom has dementia and depression since Dad died. My dad was a veteran. So is my mom. But, unless her income is below a certain standard, the VA will not provide a caregiver or even respite care. Since my mom worked her entire life and retired with a pension and social security as well as 60% of my dad's pension, then her income is too high. Regardless of her outstanding bills. And long term insurance wasn't even something anyone ever knew of, spoke of before she retired. I'm only hearing of it in recent years. She doesn't qualify for medicaid. The one thing that is available is charitable grants that will pay for respite care to a maximum each month for 3-4 months and a renewal applied for after that. Most states also have respite care programs designed to give the family caregiver a break once in awhile. The Alzheimers Society offer guidance and help even if it's not alzheimers. It's a tough situation to be in and NO ONE has the right to cast stones. And why would they? Trade places with her foe a couple weeks and get an idea as to just how physically and emotionally taxing this is.
(3)
Report
I had to reread you note a few times . I have no idea what your relationship is with your sister . I do know that BOTH of you have your hands full . I actually do know , I am into my sixth year of being the 24/7 careGIVER to a man with dementia ( mixed types. ) I watch more of who he was, die off each day .. There is no going back , ever ! Neither of you have it simple or easy . I do have some questions .
Is there a DPOA in place ? Who’s name is on it ? Is there a living will ? What is mom’s financial situation ? Does she have insurance ? Is she safe and comfortable . . Does she have others medical problems ? How about the will ? If you have has no input into any of the decisions and realistically are already overwhelmed by your husband, I see no reason to open your doors. I wish you some type of connection with your sister. Things would be easier for both of you with open conversation. There is help out there ..You just have to look for it . There are agencies and caregivers meetings . There is Hospice for your mom. There is Medicaid to help if you have to place her. There is therapy to help you and your sister. Both you and your sister would benefit if outside help was brought in . I am sure you both want MOM to be safe and
comfortable. None of us thought be would be where we are today, but it is what it is and it must be dealt with . You each have to do the best you can with what you have to work with . That is the most anyone on the outside should expect. There is NO shame and placing MOM where she will be safe .
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

You sister can choose A. Change or B. Stay the Same.

A. Change what she is doing:
From asking if you can but not hearing your reply - to asking if you can, listening & ACCEPTING your answer. You say yes or no as you need. If no, she moves on to other options: NON-family helpers (in her home or respite care).

B. Or Stay the Same..
Keep asking, not listening, not accepting, getting frustrated & resentful. Not getting respite care for Mother, not getting her holiday. Feeling then'victim'.

I'll add C. Await a Crisis.
A crisis will FORCE change upon her. Just as it does to stubborn elders who refuse help. Same.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I am not saying your sister has handled everything correctly, and I also do not think you are selfish.

But in my opinion it would not be unreasonable to give your sister a couple weeks rest a couple times a year in the short term while working on a better long term solution.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

You’re not selfish. They made the decision to take her in & now realizing what a responsibility it is. Maybe they did it for money? Anyway, tell them no. Children aren’t financially responsible for their parents. They do it out of love. If she’s difficult, they should entertain the thought s of long term care. They can hire someone or see if they can get respite care for her. Check with local AgingCenter.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
TheNewOrange Jun 2023
Of course she's selfish. That's OK, sometimes you have to be, but let's not pretend otherwise.
(0)
Report
shetay: Prayers sent.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

The term is not selfish, its selfcare. If mom is 95, I calculate, you being mid to late 60's.
Caring for a loved one ,especially parents, is not easy and regardless of who made the care arrangements, you do have a responsibility to help.
Solution: Seek out a care facility near you that will take someone for 30 days.
This will give your sibling a much needed break and you'll the opportunity to spend time with her.
You will be able to visit daily, take her on outings, or even have her spend the night with you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

The term is not selfish, its selfcare. If mom is 95, I calculate, you being mid to late 60's.
Caring for a loved one ,especially parents, is not easy and regardless of who made the care arrangements, you do have a responsibility to help.
Solution: Seek out a care facility near you that will take someone for 30 days.
This will give your sibling a much needed break and you'll the opportunity to spend time with her.
You will be able to visit daily, take her on outings, or even have her spend the night with you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This may not be what you want to hear, but my folks, in their 80's lived by themselves in their beautiful home where they moved upon retiring. My dad died suddenly 2 years ago and my mom (who had been showing early signs of dementia) slipped into a combination of depression and grief. She wasn't taking care of finances, her pets, herself. I had to step in and take over the slack. That has turned into my mom not being able to drive anymore due to getting lost. She signed power of attorney over to me. I don't make any decisions without talking to her first. Times get really bad and takes so much out of me. I'm in my early 60's and have really painful arthritis due to broken legs ans ankles and titanium in both and a long history of seizures. But I take care of her house, my house. Her yard, my yard. Her bills, my bills. Grocery shopping, laundry, her pets, my dogs. And I'm divorced, no kids. No help. No support. I don't know what experience you may have with nursing homes. They are NOT a nice place to be. No fun to work there either. I wouldn't want my worse enemy to have to live the rest of their lives in a nursing home. Do some looking into nursing home complaints and you may get just a morsel of the reality that goes on there. Residents who may need help in ambulatory to the bathroom press their call button but aren't checked on until they have soiled themselves. That is the least disgusting example I'll discuss. I have talked to my mom about her living with me, me living with her or assisted living apartment. But at the moment, I am still doing an insane amount of heavy cleaning every time I'm there, which is 2-3 times a week and spending the night at least once a week. The rest of the time, I'm breaking my back in the yard, shopping for her, talking to doctors, tax specialist, paying bills, and there is always "something" that needs fixing or replacing. I sleep about 3 hours a night, eat when I remember, and trying to find some help. I have a half sister who lives in another state who calls my mom, sends her gifts on special days. But NEVER has offered to pay for a part time caregiver or housekeeper. Because until you are thrust into the situation of being a family caregiver, then you don't get it. It's impossible to understand just how taxing it is. Coupled with the emotional part of it being your parent, your loved one. It is mentally and physically exhausting. I have found myself breaking down crying for the stupidest reasons. Someone even called Adult Protective Services to check on my welfare. I was thoroughly embarrassed. But as I found this site, and a couple great books, I realized that my feelings, tears, feeling like I could pull my hair out was just part of this whole responsibility and I'm not alone. Now I spend a great deal of time trying to find help...to give me a break. Your younger sibling, as I, can not be a proper caregiver to your mother-in-law if she isn't a proper caregiver to herself. I shook my head when I read your words. Just as my half sister treats me. As well as my mom's siblings. All have their opinions, seem to think I should throw MY MOM into a home and let her be someone else's problem. Well, this woman changed my diapers, cleaned my puke, sat up late nights, sacrificed many dreams to be a good mom to me, a good wife. She never gave her responsibility as a parent to someone else when times were tough. A martyr....really? I hardly think of myself as a martyr. But I do consider my half sister and Mom's siblings to be armchair quarterbacks who can bad mouth me, seeming to know what's best, but are nowhere to be seen. Not one of them offering any help nor even coming to visit. And never calling me to just say "how is your mom? How are you?" They have suggested that I just want to spend her money. There is no money. My credit rating dropped by 200 points in 2 years so I can take care of Mom's bills and needs first. Your sister NEEDS a vacation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
CTTN55 Jun 2023
As long as you sacrifice your own physical, mental, and emotional health in servitude to your mother, nothing will change. You know that.

So your half-sister is from your father's first marriage? (You write that you are your mother's only child.) I don't find it particularly surprising that a stepdaughter is not stepping up to help her stepmother. Do you?

What would happen to your mother if you were unable to take care of her?
(4)
Report
See 4 more replies
If you don't want to care for someone you shouldn't. It is not selfish to honor your wants and needs. I am in a similar type situation only reversed. My mom lives with me after becoming disabled from a tumor removed on her spine. The tumor stemmed from stage 4 lung cancer that metastasized to her spine and brain. This is THE hardest thing I've ever had to deal with in my life. My sister cut my mother off shortly after her diagnoses and has helped with nothing. As angry as it makes me at times I understand. If I had known what I know now I would have made different choices. In my opinion they belong in nursing homes where they have a multitude of people to care for them and their needs. It is a beautiful and noble thing to want and try to take care of your loved ones however it comes at an enormous cost. If she needs help then she can hire help for those 3 weeks or put her in a nursing home. She has other options. You can even help her find help or help fund it if that makes you feel any better. You are not selfish, your husband is not selfish. Do what is right for you first always.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
JoAnn29 Jun 2023
Just curious, why have u not placed Mom.
(4)
Report
Just want to make it clear that this is not OPs mother but her MIL.
Due to age and a stroke husband has limitations so he can't physically take care of a 95 yr old mother. OP has enough caring for her husband, let alone a MIL who seems to be hard to care for. Note too there is a 12 yr difference between siblings. I would say OP is in her 70s more likely. I will tell u right now, if I was in this position my MIL would have been placed if my husband had health problems and I was caring for him.

My Mom was in both an AL and later a NH. She was very well cared for. I never went into that NH where Mom smelled or anyone around her. She was always clean. The place was clean. The staff easy to get along with. OPs in-laws have a choice. They had a choice when they took her in.

I am 73 and I will not be caring for anyone but my DH. I have been there and done that with no help from siblings. I found I was not a Caregiver so placed Mom in an AL 5 min from me.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Perhaps a heart-to-heart with your Sister-in-law? She may not realize all that you are dealing with.

I am in your sister-in-law's position and my now 97-year old mother moved in with me 2 years ago after a stint in rehab following a hip fracture. This was in 2021 during covid so assisted living places and nursing homes were not so easy to get in to and I even wondered if it was the right thing to do at that time under those circumstances. I asked my sister to check into places with me and she wasn't receptive to helping with that at the time and it was hurtful. I've since found out she was dealing with something herself I didn't know about. And I am the daughter who had mom living next door in a what I call a "detatched in-law house" since 2009 while my sister lives over 2 hours away. She always visited though, at least once a month and often twice. She also has a son with autism so I know it's not easy.

After one full year of sole caregiving (I am a widow) I told my sister I didn't know how much longer I could do this and she brainstormed with me and she now comes to stay over night every 2-3 months for 1-3 nights, whatever she can do. It feels so good to feel some kind of support, whatever it is. And the little get-aways I have had have helped IMMENSELY. The best part was, it was her idea and I didn't have to ask. I don't know what's coming and I worry about it but at least I do not feel so alone in this anymore.

Hugs to you and Pam.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Ignore them. Do what is best for you. If you can't take on the burden of your MIL, don't. You have your hands full with your husband. Don't let someone put you on a guilt trip knowing that you don't have the strength to take this on.

They have her full time, but act like they don't enjoy her being there? Are they getting her social security check or funds? Just food for thought.

I wouldn't bother with any talks with your SIL because she sounds like she has it all planned out to dump this burden on you. Since she is playing the part of the martyr, she can find an agency to fill in as a live-in when she takes a vacation.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

No you are not being selfish.It's time to place the mom in a home.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You are not being selfish. You already have one person dependent upon you, your husband. Also, as you pointed out, you have health issues of your own.

I would suggest you help sister find a respite place. Maybe get a short list of places near where "sister" lives or get a name of a contact who can help them find respite or a permanent care home.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You are not selfish but you are in a unique position to be understanding. Since your husband has health issues, you know the work involved in his care and the emotional toll. Seems they are learning both of these. Caregiver stress is real - for you and for them. They are not evil for asking for help. You are not evil for denying to help. May I suggest that you talk with them calmly and offer suggestions. They obviously need more hands-on help and you are not in a position to give that kind of help. Suggest they ask other family members, friends, members of their faith community, home health agencies, and residential care (nursing home).
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter